The Time of Slavery by Saidiya Hartman explores the enduring impact of slavery on contemporary society, examining how historical injustices continue to shape identities and experiences within the African diaspora. Hartman delves into the complexities of memory, mourning, and the commodification of historical trauma through tourism at sites like Elmina Castle and Goree Island. This critical analysis is essential for scholars and students interested in African American studies, history, and cultural memory. The work interrogates the relationship between past and present, emphasizing the necessity of remembering the dead while grappling with the ongoing legacy of slavery. Ideal for those studying the intersections of history, race, and memory in the context of the African diaspora.

Key Points

  • Analyzes the relationship between slavery and contemporary identity in the African diaspora.
  • Explores the role of tourism in shaping collective memory of slavery at historical sites.
  • Examines the complexities of mourning and memory in the context of historical trauma.
  • Discusses the ongoing legacy of slavery and its impact on modern society.
Giulia Picco
22 pages
Giulia Picco
22 pages
308
/ 22
The Time of Slavery
Saidiya V. Hartman
The South Atlantic Quarterly, Volume 101, Number 4, Fall 2002, pp.
757-777 (Article)
Published by Duke University Press
For additional information about this article
https://muse.jhu.edu/article/39111
[154.59.125.170] Project MUSE (2025-04-04 07:06 GMT) Universita Studi di Torino
Saidiya Hartman
The Time of Slavery
For to me history was not a large stage filled with
commemoration, bands, cheers, ribbons, medals, the
sound of fine glass clinking and raised high in the air;
in other words, the sounds of victory. For me history
was not only the past: it was the past and it was also
the present. I did not mind my defeat, I only minded
that it had to last so long; I did not see the future, and
that is perhaps as it should be.
—Jamaica Kincaid, The Autobiography of My Mother
Slavery here is a ghost, both the past and the living
presence; and the problem of historical representation
is how to represent the ghost.
—Michel-Rolph Trouillot, Silencing the Past
A memorial plaque posted near the entryway
of the courtyard of Elmina Castle reads, ‘In
everlasting memory of the anguish of our ances-
tors. May those who died rest in peace. May
those who return find their roots. May humanity
never again perpetrate such injustice against
humanity.Wethelivingvowtoupholdthis.’As
the plaque suggests, reckoning with our respon-
sibility to the dead necessitates not only our
remembrance but also a promise to forswear
the injustice that enabled this crime against hu-
manity to occur. It would appear that our lives
The South Atlantic Quarterly :, Fall .
Copyright ©  by Duke University Press.
[154.59.125.170] Project MUSE (2025-04-04 07:06 GMT) Universita Studi di Torino
758 Saidiya Hartman
and even those of the dead depend on such acts of remembrance. Yet how
best to remember the dead and represent the past is an issue fraught with
difficulty, if not outright contention.
The difficulty posed by the plaque’s injunction to remember is as much
the faith it bespeaks in the redressive capacities of memory, as the con-
fidence it betrays in the founding distinction or break between then and
now. For the distinction between the past and the present founders on the
interminable grief engendered by slavery and its aftermath. How might we
understand mourning, when the event has yet to end? When the injuries not
only perdure, but are inflicted anew? Can one mourn what has yet ceased
happening? The point here is not to deny the abolition of slavery or to assert
the identity or continuity of racism over the course of centuries, but rather
to consider the constitutive nature of loss in the making of the African dias-
pora and the role of grief in transatlantic identification, especially in light
of the plaque’s behest that those returning find their roots, which is second
only to the desire that the dead rest in peace.
I attempt to grapple with these questions by examining the role of tour-
ism as a vehicle of memory, specifically tourist performances at Cape Coast
Castle and Elmina Castle in Ghana and at La Maison de Esclaves on Goree
Island, Senegal, and the ways in which the identifications and longings of
the tourist, the formulas of roots tourism, and the economic needs of Afri-
can states shape, affect, and influence our understanding of slavery and in
concert produce a collective memory of the past.
1
As the plaque intimates, to remember the dead is to mend ruptured
lines of descent and filiation. In this regard, remembrance is entangled with
reclaiming the past, propitiating ancestors, and recovering the origins of the
descendants of this dispersal. To remember slavery is to imagine the past as
the ‘‘fabric of our own experience’’ and seizing hold of it as ‘‘the key to our
identity.
2
And the belated return of the African-American tourist is fraught
with these issues. The fixation on roots reveals the centrality of identity not
only to the transactions of tourism, but in staging the encounter with the
past. Identification and bereavement are inextricably linked in this instance;
since the roots we are encouraged to recover presuppose the rupture of the
transatlantic slave trade and the natal alienation and kinlessness of enslave-
ment. Put differently, the issues of loss and our identification with the dead
are central to both the work of mourning and the political imagination of the
African diaspora.
3
And, for this reason, grief is a central term in the political
vocabulary of the diaspora.
/ 22
End of Document
308

FAQs

What themes are explored in The Time of Slavery?
The Time of Slavery examines themes of memory, identity, and the ongoing impact of slavery on contemporary society. Hartman explores how historical injustices shape the experiences of individuals within the African diaspora, emphasizing the need to remember and honor those who suffered. The work also critiques the commodification of slavery through tourism, questioning how these narratives are constructed and presented. By intertwining personal and collective histories, Hartman highlights the complexities of mourning and the necessity of confronting the past.
How does Hartman address the concept of tourism in relation to slavery?
Hartman critiques the role of tourism in shaping collective memory of slavery, particularly at sites like Elmina Castle and Goree Island. She argues that these tourist experiences often commodify historical trauma, transforming the narrative of suffering into a spectacle for consumption. This commodification raises questions about authenticity and the ethical implications of remembering the past through a commercial lens. Hartman suggests that while tourism can facilitate remembrance, it can also obscure the deeper realities of the historical injustices faced by enslaved individuals.
What is the significance of mourning in The Time of Slavery?
Mourning is a central theme in The Time of Slavery, as Hartman explores how the act of remembering the dead is intertwined with the identities of their descendants. She argues that the grief associated with slavery is not merely a relic of the past but a living presence that continues to affect contemporary experiences. Hartman emphasizes the importance of acknowledging this grief as a means of understanding the ongoing legacy of slavery and its impact on modern society. By grappling with the complexities of mourning, Hartman invites readers to reflect on their own connections to history and memory.
What methodologies does Hartman use in her analysis?
Hartman employs a multidisciplinary approach in The Time of Slavery, combining historical analysis with cultural critique and personal narrative. She draws on a range of sources, including historical documents, literary texts, and contemporary accounts, to illustrate the enduring impact of slavery. By weaving together these different strands, Hartman creates a rich tapestry of insights that challenge conventional narratives about the past. Her methodology encourages readers to engage critically with the complexities of memory and identity in the context of the African diaspora.
What impact does The Time of Slavery have on the understanding of African American history?
The Time of Slavery significantly impacts the understanding of African American history by highlighting the ongoing relevance of slavery's legacy in contemporary society. Hartman's work challenges readers to confront the uncomfortable truths of historical injustices and their present-day implications. By emphasizing the interconnectedness of past and present, she encourages a deeper engagement with the complexities of identity, memory, and cultural heritage. This critical perspective is essential for scholars, students, and anyone interested in the nuanced narratives of African American history.